Santa Cruz Good Times

Saturday
Oct 25th
Text size
  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size

An Invitation to a ‘Thought Experiment’

don_laneI’d like to invite every “housed” person in our community to join me in a “thought experiment.” It’s pretty simple. When you climb into bed tonight, pull the covers over you and look up at the ceiling, pause for a moment and imagine that you are homeless.

Imagine you’re about to go to sleep under a tree or a bridge somewhere … you’re on a piece of damp cardboard with a couple of dirty blankets. You haven’t had a shower in several days (you had one after waiting for a few hours at the homeless center last week). As you try to go to sleep, think about what you’re wearing: the same clothes you wore all day today…and yesterday and the day before. Imagine how safe you are feeling with no walls around you and no door to lock. Imagine that every material thing you have is in a single bag, which you are using as a pillow. Now imagine that it’s starting to rain…and you hear footsteps approaching.

Now imagine you are the same homeless person in the scenario above walking down the street, carrying your rolled up blankets and your bag—doing nothing illegal—encountering “housed” people around the community. The shop owner. The police officer. The family on a walk. Imagine what looks and non-verbal signals you (as a homeless person) typically get from these citizens. Now imagine getting those signals every day, everywhere you go. How does this compare with your own typical interactions as you (as a “housed” person) encounter the shop owner and the family and the cop?

Hold these images in your mind as you ask yourself what you believe about the issue of homelessness in our community.

Do you think Santa Cruz does too much or not enough for homeless people here? What do you know about the quantity of services available here? Is there enough shelter? Are there adequate, available programs to help homeless people with substance abuse or mental health problems?

What are the chances of a homeless person getting a job if their sleeping/living situation matches the one described above?  Once a person has been homeless for awhile, what would it take for them to get back to a more “normal” life?

OK, I’ve asked too many questions.

If it’s not apparent already, I’m suggesting that many of us housed people don’t think about these things enough. If we did, I believe more of us would be conscious of how hard and unsafe and unhealthy and unfriendly life on the streets is for most homeless people.

I believe people would make fewer assumptions along the lines of “they have it easy because they don’t have to go to work each day.” (Ignoring the fact that many homeless people do have jobs.) In general, we’d realize homelessness is a much bigger problem for homeless people than it is for the rest of us who find it troublesome or bothersome only when we encounter it. I don’t think so many of us would wish to push homeless people away and, instead, we would think more about how we might contribute to addressing homelessness realistically and constructively. I think this will be especially true when people stop ignoring the fact (shown in several surveys) that the great majority of homeless people in our area lived here before they became homeless.

This is not a plea to allow aggressive panhandling or illegal drug use. Nor is it a plea to ignore the damage caused by filthy campsites in our parks. It is a plea to recognize that stopping these behaviors and messes will not fundamentally change the fact that there are more than 2200 homeless people in the Santa Cruz area and shelter beds for well under 20 percent of those people. And with unemployment at 15 percent, we need to move beyond blame and get to work on constructive strategies.

If you’d like to get involved, there are many opportunities. Help the Homeless Services Center or other local homeless service programs as a volunteer or a donor. Contribute to the new Imagine Positive Change donation program to provide a positive alternative to giving to panhandlers and to provide funds to assist people in getting off the street. Volunteer one day this year or make a donation to help Project Homeless Connect (March 30 at the Civic Auditorium), a multi-service event delivering practical resources to homeless individuals while providing an opportunity for housed residents to work directly with the realities of homelessness. Or work with your church or other faith-based organization or a community volunteer group that that is assisting the poorest people among us.


Don Lane is a City Councilmember and a volunteer board member at the Homeless Services Center.  Comments on this article via email to This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .

Comments (4)Add Comment
Compassion is never misplaced
written by Vern Foske, January 30, 2011
But "idiot compassion" is. I find it interesting that Don Lane, here, and others involved with HSC insist that most people helped are local, when, in fact, they say otherwise officially--up to 70% helped are non-local. We ARE a magnet because outside communities bus their problematic people here.

See:

http://www.santacruzsentinel.com/ci_16570464?IADID=Search-www.santacruzsentinel.com-www.santacruzsentinel.com

...
written by John Hohn, May 19, 2010
Don, I have imagined all these things. In fact, I imagine most of them quite frequently.

Imagining these things is what caused me to study hard in school.

Imagining these things is what gets me out of bed every day at 5:30 to go to a job I don't like.

Imagining these things is what caused our ancestors to get off their duffs to hunt and gather and provide for their familes.

Without these consequences, I might just lay around and play the guitar with my homies and smoke dope, which I do enjoy.

People only do what they have to do. I learned this lesson while raising three children.

Please stop encouraging transients to stay in Santa Cruz, where there are no jobs and thus virtually no chance for them to actually change their lives in any permanent, meaningful way.
Imagine this....Just saying...
written by concerned citizen, March 28, 2010
Imagine , being a newcomer to the community and getting approached and then accosted by a Panhandler /"homeless" person. At just about every block , imagine being fearful for your life because they start yelling obscenities at you when you do not give them money. Imagine being a person who actually watches a, per their own sign, "homeless person" drive away in a new SUV or a brand new bicycle and then calls someone on their cell phone. Imagine getting a fearful panicked call from your 16 year old daughter going downtown for lunch during school because she is getting cat called to with with rude obscenitys from street people, Imagine the consent smell of urine on the streets just like in SF especially on a warm summer day, gross and scary especially for some one coming from a town with zero tolerance for this.

Wake up Santa Cruz it is out of control. "Homeless "or vagabond travelers come to Santa Cruz because it is tolerated. Santa Cruz is overwhelmed. As for those who are truly homeless who want to work and who need these services and want to change their circumstances and not be chronically homeless, Yes I support help for them. Yes we need jobs too in Santa Cruz. I think the focus should be on jobs creation, and transitional help. I think the surrounding communities need to pitch in more as well.
What is the definition of homeless? Whom should we help? the vagabond travelers ,who come to this town and beg for drug money, to get their next fix at heroin hill , to support the GANG drug dealers who STAB our children? The gang drug dealers come because we have a large population of addicts. The drug dealers make a lot of money off those addicts. the addicts get their money through begging and stealing etc. Small crimes breed violent crimes.

I think the homeless who had security once, and are families displaced by the economic downturn who are trying hard to get back on their feet, they need help the most. and older people who can't work they need support. There is a disconnect between those who are criminals acting like they are homeless or choosing to be homeless and those who are truly in need of the homeless services, We need to figure this out first,
Compassion is never misplaced
written by Tim Goncharoff, March 25, 2010
Thanks for writing this, Donnie, knowing full well how many nasty comments you will get. Having leaders like you is one of the things that makes me feel proud of where we live.

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

Share this on your social networks

Bookmark and Share

Share this

Bookmark and Share

 

Santa Cruz Restaurant Week

A huge part of Santa Cruz Restaurant Week has always been about offering a great dining experience for an affordable price. For some locals, the $25 flat-rate cost has provided the opportunity (or the excuse!) to try new spots, and indulge in Santa Cruz fine dining in a way they might have thought too pricey before.

 

Scorpio Sun, New Moon Eclipse, Mercury Direct

The Sun enters Scorpio’s mysteries Thursday under a new moon and partial solar eclipse (something essential has come to an end, its purpose completed). In Scorpio we harbor secrets, are devoted to something deep, dark and hidden. Sometimes it’s ourselves. We can bring great suspect to our assessment of others. Scorpio is the scorpion, the serpent and the eagle—three levels of development. As the serpent we take shelter in our beliefs. Sometimes we bite (or sting). The eagle vanquishes old beliefs through its sharp intellect, soaring high in the air, seeking to understand through perspective. Understanding releases us from the bondage of fear. The eagle is like the mother soothing feelings of mistrust, offering protection. Knowledge does this, too.

 

The New Tech Nexus

Community leaders in science and technology unite to form web-based networking program

 

Light Humor

College comedy questions a post-racial America in ‘Dear White People’
Sign up for Good Times weekly newsletter
Get the latest news, events

RSS Feed Burner

 Subscribe in a reader

Latest Comments

 

Back Porch

Austin Kaye on backyard dinners and why it’s his favorite time of year to be a chef

 

What’s the most outrageous situation you ever saw at a restaurant?

Damani Thomas, Santa Cruz, Chef/Owner

 

Wine Lust

The Spanish Godello grape, plus arancinis, tender butter lettuce and pork schnitzel at Soif

 

What artist or artists participating in the encore weekend of Open Studios should not be missed?

Santa Cruz | Teacher