Santa Cruz Good Times

Wednesday
Apr 01st
Text size
  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size

Martinelli’s Goes Against the Flow

news1_JohnMartinelliFamed Watsonville cider company rejects water fluoridation, builds own well
When Watsonville accepted $1.6 million from the California Dental Association Foundation to fluoridate the city’s water on Sept. 28, the hope was that the new system would reduce tooth decay, particularly among the poor. But what happens when one of the biggest employers, water consumers and most well-known businesses in town is vehemently against fluoridation?

Such is the dilemma currently facing John Martinelli, president of world famous juice maker S. Martinelli & Co.

A strong opponent of fluoridation, Martinelli has played a key role in the decade-long struggle to convince the Watsonville City Council that fluoride has not been proven safe or effective. But with a state law that says cities with 10,000 or more people must fluoridate if costs are covered by an outside agency, a refusal to comply would mean a fine of $200 per day against the city.

Regardless of the penalty, Martinelli sees it as a violation of human rights. “We really believe that fluoridation is morally and ethically wrong,” he says. “People should not be subjected to medicine without their consent. It should be a person’s choice.”

While Watsonville councilmembers Nancy Bilicich, Greg Caput and Emilio Martinez opposed fluoridation in the 4-3 vote that set the plan in motion, theirs and Martinelli’s pleas were no match to what the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has called “one of 10 great public health achievements of the 20th century.”

news1_maeteneli2But that doesn’t mean that Martinelli won’t do everything in his power to stop it from impacting his 142-year-old family business.

Prior to this summer, the company, which created nonalcoholic cider as a stand-in for champagne during Prohibition, would not have been impacted by fluoridation due to the fact that none of their 100-percent juices and ciders contains water. However, Martinelli’s new Fruit Virtues line of acai, pomegranate, gogi and blueberry juices use water to reconstitute concentrate.

For this reason, Martinelli has decided to detach his company from the city’s water supply and build his own well.

A costly venture estimated at around $300,000, Martinelli’s plans to use its own money to drill down to the uncontaminated Aromas Red Sands Aquifer. While the president is not at all thrilled to have to invest in a well, he does not believe they have a choice with the fluoridation system estimated to be up and running in the next two years.

“We can’t believe that the city is taking good water and ruining it,” says Martinelli. “The well will cost a significant amount of money that we don’t have, but we don’t feel that we can ask the city to help us pay for it. Each resident should have the opportunity to ask the city for reverse fluoridation.”

According to the American Dental Association, Watsonville residents are now a part of the projected 72.4 percent of the U.S. population served by public water systems that receive optimally fluoridated water. Other fluoridated cities in California include Los Angeles, Long Beach, Beverly Hills and Huntington Beach.

The Association claims that fluoridation, which was first implemented in Grand Rapids, Mich. in 1945, works by halting or reversing decay and keeping tooth enamel strong. And many local dentists seem to agree, calling Watsonville’s dental hygiene “an epidemic” that needs immediate attention. Michelle Simon, a pediatrician whose joint practice cares for 6,000 Watsonville children, told the L.A. Times that she “has never seen such bad teeth outside Nicaragua.”

But critics across the country continue to believe that health officials are distorting scientific studies and lying about fluoride’s relation to thyroid problems, kidney malfunction and fetal damage.

If Martinelli’s were to continue depending on the city’s water system, they have no doubt that suspicious customers would boycott their products altogether.

“We’ve received quite a bit of feedback since we’ve stood up to fluoridation,” says Martinelli. “Ninety-percent of that feedback has been appreciative with the majority of our consumers agreeing with us and the other 10 percent are passionately upset that we’ve fought it.”

While a number of Santa Cruz residents have been attending meetings and actively supporting the company’s rejection of fluoridated water, Martinelli warns Watsonville’s neighbor to the north that they’re coming for us next.

“Santa Cruz may not want fluoridation,” says Martinelli. “But they have to know they’re on the list.”

The state has been attempting to fluoridate both cities for years, but in 1999 Santa Cruz prohibited the additive with an initiative known as Measure N and just four years later it was banned in Watsonville with Measure S.

At first, the decision to fluoridate in Watsonville caused Martinelli to consider moving his company, which placed Watsonville on the global map, out of the city. But local officials have since urged him to stay.

“We definitely feel that the city appreciates us and wants to keep us in the community, even offering to provide us with fluoride-free water,” says Martinelli. “But we’re not interested in being a special case with a separate hook up. That would just cause backlash from residents and other businesses.”

Surprisingly, Martinelli’s is one of the only major companies in Watsonville that relies on city water. Del Mar Food Products has their own well and so did Smuckers and Birds Eye Foods, Inc.

Losing Martinelli’s as a water consumer, when the company’s annual water expenses exceed $100,000 per year, is a huge risk for the city that is already facing a $5 million deficit. But considering that Watsonville’s newly adopted contract with the California Dental Association Foundation ensures that they will fund the fluoridation systems, operating and maintenance for the next two years, they may be able to cushion the blow.

Much of the buzz surrounding the September decision to fluoridate appears to have died down—including the threat to fight the law all the way to the Supreme Court—but Martinelli remains firm in his position that city residents should not be exposed to it.

“Fluoride is not an essential nutrient for the body,” he says. “And while most people agree that it works when applied topically, there are no tests to prove that it reduces tooth decay when ingested—in fact, it’s been linked to osteoporosis and cancer, and it’s on the California Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment ‘watch list’ of Prop 65 chemicals.”

The biggest problem, according to Martinelli, is that few people or small businesses have the money and resources to opt out of fluoridation even if they want to.

“This was not a vote against Martinelli’s,” he says. “But Watsonville could have at least driven a hard bargain instead of giving the foundation what they wanted.”

Comments (1)Add Comment
The Time Has Come
written by Informed, January 02, 2011
A clear sign from those in charge that you WILL do as instructed. One only has to open a detailed history book to find similar motivation in nazi germany prison camps.

f you believe all of this is 'just a coincidence' - go ahead and keep brushing your teeth with your 'fluoride' toothpaste and sucking on your sodium fluoride enhanced Coke or Pepsi product - for ignorance truly is bliss and you truly deserve what you get.


Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

Share this on your social networks

Bookmark and Share

Share this

Bookmark and Share

 

Panel Discussion

After 39 years in business, the owner of Santa Cruz’s Atlantis Fantasyworld looks back at how comics have evolved

 

Passion Week, Eclipse, Full Moon, Aries Festival, Passover and Easter

We have entered a most important week of multiple festivals. Three ages and religious festivals—stages for humanity’s development—are occurring simultaneously. Aries (Age of Laws), Pisces (Age of Faith), and Aquarian (Age of Science and Humanity); Jewish, Christian/Catholic and Esoteric teachings. The first of the three Spring Festivals occurs Saturday along with the full moon, a total lunar eclipse (something in form and matter has come to an end, its usefulness completed). It’s also Passover, celebrating the passage from the Taurus to the Aries Age, symbolized by the Hebrew people’s walk of 40 years from Egypt through the Sinai Desert to Canaan (land of milk and honey), culminating with Moses receiving the 10 Commandments—laws that directed humanity through the Aries Age. Passover celebrates their safe passage out of Egypt, “the Angel passing over the Jewish homes, safeguarding their first born.” The Aries Festival (first of three Spring Festivals—Aries, Taurus, Gemini) celebrates the love of God. Accompanying the Aries light (light of life itself) are the forces of restoration (restoring humanity’s hope) and the spirit of resurrection (uplifting humanity in need of new education, resources, direction and guidance). Guidance to be given by the New Group of World Servers. Saturday’s solar Aries festival (at the full moon lunar eclipse) is celebrated by the New Group of World Servers worldwide. Join us everyone. Sunday is Easter, celebrated by humanity worldwide. The three religious festivals arriving simultaneously signal that the coming new world religion is at hand, a synthesis and integration of all religions. We stand with our brothers and sisters everywhere in celebration. We see what is no longer needed—that which created separations between us—disappear. We stand forward together in the new light, with the spirit of resurrection directing us. Hosanna!

 

The New Tech Nexus

Community leaders in science and technology unite to form web-based networking program

 

Let’s Get Wrecked

Unsung ’60s musicians score in pop doc ‘The Wrecking Crew’
Sign up for Good Times weekly newsletter
Get the latest news, events

RSS Feed Burner

 Subscribe in a reader

Latest Comments

 

Wheat Will Rock You

Companion Bakeshop scores again with Ryan Roseman’s harvest

 

What’s the best/worst April Fools’ Day prank you’ve ever heard?

This girl in my seventh grade class convinced our entire Christian school that she had cancer. Everybody started praying for her and stopped all the classes. At the end of the day she let everybody know it was an April Fools’ joke. Zach Scotton, Santa Cruz, Retail Manager

 

Odonata Wines

Easter is coming up this weekend, the perfect excuse to treat yourself and your loved ones to a little bit of bubbly with Easter brunch—and a special bubbly at that.

 

Ella’s at the Airport

Tiffany Ella King on her new fine dining restaurant in Watsonville