Santa Cruz Good Times

Aug 02nd
Text size
  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size

The Gore-y Truth

news1Climate change crusader Al Gore engages local youth
Former Vice President and Nobel Peace Prize winner Al Gore opened his May 17 talk at California State University Monterey Bay with a classic quote from anthropologist Margaret Mead: “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever does.”

Every seat was taken for the fourth lecture in the annual series hosted by the Panetta Institute, a CSUMB-based nonpartisan educational foundation focused on public policy. The roughly 800 students in attendance came from campuses throughout the Central Coast, and the processes used to select them for participation were as diverse as the region itself. Later in the evening, Gore would speak at an $85-per-ticket event at the Golden State Theatre in Monterey (broadcast live on local television). But here, the crowd would be tougher to play to—after all, it rests on the slim shoulders of the students in this room and their generation to make amends for the climate crisis.

Gore’s most recent book came out in paperback in November 2009. Titled “Our Choice: A Plan to Solve the Climate Crisis,” it finds America’s climate change action hero still sober and thoughtful, with opinions to spare. The book boldly declares: “It is now abundantly clear that we have at our fingertips all of the tools we need to solve the climate crisis. The only missing ingredient is collective will.” Like most American action heroes, this potential protagonist has been exposed to a broad-base of finger-wagging and nit-picking, as well as a general loss of focus on the challenging antagonist at hand: the monster climate crisis threatening to undo us all.

Frank Sesno, director of the School of Media and Public Affairs at George Washington University and host of PBS’ “Planet Forward” moderated, asking Gore pre-selected questions written by students.

Questions and Answers

Gore opened the discussion with Central Coast students by recalling a time in his own youth when he was always asking “Why?”

“I wrote ‘Inconvenient Truth’ and now I understand there is a group calling themselves ‘inconvenient youth’ … So today I ask, tell me why it’s OK to put millions of tons of carbon [dioxide] into the atmosphere every day?” he posed.

An affable speaker, Gore’s presence is unmistakably Southern, and his manner of addressing issues can be circuitous, in the gentlemanly way of a senator’s son from Nashville, Tenn.

But students were up on their current events and didn’t hold back on the tough questions. UC Santa Cruz student Eric Deardorff was responsible for one of the afternoon’s less scripted moments. Circumventing the pre-selected question format, he stood up and interjected, “Mr. Vice President, in regard to your literature, you state the single most effective thing you can do to reduce your carbon footprint is to stop eating meat. I was wondering if today you could commit to doing what you say in your literature?” Gore responded by saying that he has cut back on his meat consumption, but is not a vegetarian—something he added is “a personal choice.”

The majority of hard-hitting questions, however, were focused on the Gulf Coast oil spill. One question on the topic asked about how major corporations such as BP and Exxon Mobil could be held accountable for their actions. “We need to put a price tag on using the atmosphere as an open sewer,” he replied, adding that changes need to be made to current laws and regulations and that a global treaty would help.

He encouraged the students to question the reasons for offshore oil drilling. “I would not buy into the idea that our energy independence depends in any way on offshore drilling,” he said.

Students asked him why, in the face of overwhelming evidence, some people persist in believing global warming doesn’t exist.

Given the opportunity, how would he respond to those individuals in one minute or less? “Even if you don’t believe it’s happening, help the U.S. quit depending on foreign oil,” he replied.

On that note, they inquired as to how they could affect change themselves. The answer was simple: get involved. “The single best thing we can do for climate change is to take action ourselves,” he said. “If you want to make a difference, you really can.”

Continuing, Gore waxed poetic, recounting his memory of when, as a 13-year-old, President John F. Kennedy put a pledge out that the United States would have the first man to walk on the moon. At the time, this was controversial. Many people thought it was irresponsible. Yet the dream became a reality, and when it did, the average age of the mission engineers was 26. That means when JFK made the pledge, these engineers were an average age of 18 years old. His message here was clear: youth can and have shaped our country.

In closing, Vice President Gore expressed his hope that some of the students in the room would consider going into public service. “Just remember to hold true to the people you represent,” he said.

Overall Impressions

The event may have raised as many questions as it answered: Are we just making nice while the planet goes up in flames? Do we really have time to gather 800 bright young minds and send them out into the world without a clear directive for action? Why was the action-oriented arm of Al Gore's nonprofit The Alliance for Climate Protection and absent from the conversation?

Still, most of the students interviewed by Good Times say they gained a great deal of insight into the political process and the complexities of the issues.

Shelby Funk, a Cabrillo College student who is preparing for a degree in International Studies, felt that it was important to hear about individual empowerment and change through technology. “I really liked the points that were made as far as using social networking and the Internet to make change happen on a grassroots level,” she says. “I was encouraged to hear how these tools are influencing policy. I would like to see multi-national corporations held accountable for their actions.”

UCSC students Michael Peters and Shawn Freeman, who are both involved in community outreach, say it was a great example of community education and organization. Peters, a major in American Studies, is on his way to dual internships in Boston. “I will be working for AVOYCE, which is connected to the Asian Development Corporation and also CIGSYA, a gay youth organization,” he says. “This presentation was strong from the point of view of bringing people together and building advocacy.”

Freeman, who will be graduating in the Environmental Sustainable Living Program, has done work for Friends of the Urban Forest in San Francisco and sees his future involved with the development of sustainable gardens. He was impressed with the event’s panel of educators who presented climate change issues as they are related to marine science, but he left with one qualm with the overall event. “I will admit I was a bit disappointed that when Gore was asked what he had done in his personal life to reduce his carbon footprint, all the things he listed were out of reach to high school and college students,” he says. “I think this could have been stronger and more pertinent.”


This lecture and more can be found at Take action or learn more by visiting,, or Pamela Biery is a freelance writer and communication consultant living in Felton. She writes for Sacramento News & Review, Airstream Life and other publications.
Comments (1)Add Comment
written by Lost 17, May 27, 2010
The real Gore-y Truth is this is one man who will never have an open debate on the issues. And you have to wonder why I've listened to the Panetta Lecture series for years, and this is one of the only times I've heard, someone who has had handed to him an open platform to propagandize his positions. Total hypocrite. "stop eating meat", yet his personal choice is to only cut back. And I really wonder who will profit from his carbon offset program? It's funny to think that he offsets his own carbon footprint by paying offsets to a company he holds an interest in, Generation Investment Management. This guy does not want to save the planet, he is more worried about controlling others and what they eat, drive, and how they live, and making a profit off of it.
I don't really have a deep enough understanding of the situation to have an educated position, but if this is the leader of the "Stop Climate Change", movement, I have a hard time believing that he wants anything more than to dig into my wallet. 'Cause I hope everyone knows that if something like Cap and Trade goes through, WE WILL BE PAYING THE BILL, not CORPORATIONS, they will only pass the increases in fees and fines along to the consumer. Wake up unless you want the Government controlling your thermostat, the time you spend in your car, the time you spend in the shower, and other things I can't think of right now. One final thought; has anyone thought about how our coast lines have formed? Do you think they ALWAYS looked like they do now? If so you need to go back to 6 grade science class. WAKE UP WAKE UP WAKE UP

Write comment
smaller | bigger


Share this on your social networks

Bookmark and Share

Share this

Bookmark and Share


Health Screening

Santa Cruz wellness expert releases app to improve workplace well-being


Leo Sun; Full Moon, Venus Retro in Leo; Saturn Direct

It’s a complex week of planetary movements, challenges, demands and callings. We’re in the time of the Leo Sun. Leo—fixed fire, gold, the heart, generous, strong, noble, the king/queen—needs appreciation and praise from everyone in order to move forward. During Leo we gain a greater sense of self-identification by recognizing our creativity. It’s therefore a perfect time for Venus retrograding in Leo. In Venus retrograde we review and re-assess values. Venus retro in Leo concerns our self as valuable, acknowledging talents, gifts, abilities and offerings. Friday, Venus re-enters Leo (29 degrees, a critical degree) continuing the retrograde to 14 degrees Leo on Sept. 6. Friday (Full Moon) is also the (8 degrees) Leo solar festival, Festival of the Future. Leo is the heart of the sun, the heart of all that matters. When attuned to this heart, we have understanding and inclusivity. The heart of the Lion is Mitra (think “Maitreya,” the coming World Teacher). Leo prepares humanity to receive divine love from subtle sources and later to radiate that love to the kingdoms. Sirius, Ray 2, where love originates, streams through Regulus (heart of Leo), into the heart of the sun (Ray 2) and into all hearts. The heart of Leo is Regulus. Joining Venus, the love underlying all of creation appears. Saturday is Sun/Neptune (confusion or devotion) with late night Saturn turning stationary direct. Ideas, plans and structures held long in abeyance (since March 14) slowly move forward. (Read more on Leo and the week at and Risa D’Angeles’ Facebook page, accessed through my website.)


The New Tech Nexus

Community leaders in science and technology unite to form web-based networking program


Film, Times & Events: Week of July 31

Santa Cruz area movie theaters >
Sign up for Good Times weekly newsletter
Get the latest news, events

RSS Feed Burner

 Subscribe in a reader

Latest Comments


Holy Cannoli

New bakery opens in Ben Lomond, plus Randall Grahm’s quest to grow 10,000 new grape varieties, and Mexican cooking classes


Is Santa Cruz turning into Malibu North?

It's got a ways to go before it gets wrecked like Malibu, but I think we need to be very careful about growth. Maria Mattioli, Santa Cruz, Psychotherapist


Bargetto Winery

A much-anticipated annual event at Bargetto Winery is the release of their very special La Vita red wine. June 7 was the day to be heralded this year, and I happily squeezed my car into their overloaded car park in eager anticipation of tasting the new La Vita nectar.



Popular Capitola spot gets new owner and complete makeover