Santa Cruz Good Times

Saturday
Dec 27th
Text size
  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size

The Crisis Continues…

news1-1Foreclosures may increase in 2012

Despite the nationwide legal settlement announced last month between 49 state attorney generals and major banks over fraudulent foreclosure practices, and despite a downward trend in the number of homes entering the foreclosure process both locally and statewide compared to this time last year, the damage done by the collapse of the housing market continues in Santa Cruz County. More than 100 Notices of Default and 120 Notices of Sale are issued (on average) by banks each month.

Although reports show that foreclosures are beginning to slow in California, an estimated one in 354 homes in Santa Cruz County received a notice of foreclosure in January (compared to one in 265 homes statewide), and roughly a third of homeowners are still underwater, or owe more on their homes than they are worth in the current market, according to ForeclosureRadar.

Almost four years after its inception, and without one major bank official brought to trial, the foreclosure crisis has piqued the anger, energy and outreach of the Occupy movement across the country. Led by Occupy Santa Cruz’s Foreclosure Working Group, a March To Stop Foreclosures took a tour of major bank branches in Downtown Santa Cruz, drawing a crowd of roughly 200 protestors, without incident, on March 11.

 “The stipulated agreement is a beginning, a down payment, for past fraudulent banking practices.” says Steve Pleich, an organizer of Occupy Santa Cruz. “There must be, and will be, much more to come if the economic balance between lenders and homeowners is to be restored.”    

With Notices of Default across California down 11.9 percent in the fourth quarter of 2011 compared to the fourth quarter of 2010, Sean O’Toole, CEO of ForeclosureRadar, wrote on the company’s website, “January’s numbers should put to rest any notion that we will see a wave of foreclosures in 2012, at least in Western states that we cover.”

But that optimism is not shared by Daren Blomquist, vice president of RealtyTrac, Inc. Blomquist said federal and state probes into fraudulent foreclosure practices last year, exemplified by the “robo-signing” scandal, slowed down foreclosures in 2011. Now that major banks have settled on their liability for illegal practices and the rules of foreclosure are clearer, a new wave of foreclosures is ensuing.

“The settlement will accelerate the foreclosures that are happening this year and it will accelerate the process of lenders catching up on the backlog of foreclosures,” Blomquist told the Associated Press last month. RealtyTrac predicts foreclosures will increase by 25 percent nationwide in 2012 to roughly 1 million homes, compared to the 804,000 homes lenders took back last year.

“California communities and families are being devastated by the mortgage and foreclosure crisis. We must ensure the deceptive practices that caused it never happen again,” Attorney General Kamala Harris said in a press release last month announcing a raft of legislation labeled the “California Homeowner Bill of Rights,” legislation required to implement the bank settlement. Harris played a major role in getting the best deal for California throughout more than a year of intense negotiations with the banks, resulting in California receiving $18 billion out of the $25 billion settlement. About $10 million of the total is earmarked for loan principal write-downs on first and second loans for homeowners who are underwater and behind on their payments.    

Moody’s Analytics released a report last month that states,  “Bank of America, Wells Fargo, J.P. Morgan, and Citigroup have each publicly disclosed the settlement will have little or no additional effect on the banks …. loan loss reserves mostly cover the related costs.” The report highlights, however, that banks received no immunity from further prosecution for highly leveraged gambling with mortgage-backed securities that caused the financial collapse in 2008.

Local Responses

Especially when it hits a friend or neighbor in his district, County Supervisor John Leopold says the foreclosure crises is “a very heavy weight I carry around.”  Leopold has taken a lead in what the county can do to reduce the number and the damage done by foreclosures on both his constituents and the county budget. With property values dropping roughly 30 percent since 2008, property tax receipts to Santa Cruz County government decreased by roughly $10 million in the 2009-10 fiscal year alone, according to Auditor-Controller Mary Jo Walker.  

news1-2An Occupy Santa Cruz-led March To Stop Foreclosures took a tour of major bank branches in Downtown Santa Cruz on March 11. Photo by Sal Ingram.Leopold looked across the country for examples of what other jurisdictions have tried, and is discouraged. Providence, R.I., for example, passed an ordinance requiring good-faith negotiations prior to a foreclosure, overseen by a third-party housing counselor, and was promptly sued by a group of local banks. The court allowed the mediation program, but ruled against the city’s authority to block transfer of ownership unless approved by the mediator, according to Leopold.

Leopold is particularly frustrated by a state law that apparently precludes counties or cities from initiating their own, more stringent mortgage mediation requirements prior to foreclosure, or, as advocated for by the Occupy Foreclosure Working Group, mandating a moratorium on foreclosures until the legality of foreclosures is certain.

Hailed as emergency assistance at the height of the financial crises in 2008, SB 1137 required a minimum of mediation efforts by banks prior to foreclosure. These basic requirements were characterized by Leopold as “incredibly wimpy … in some cases simply requiring nothing more than a phone call and a point of contact.” Particularly egregious to Leopold is that this state law preempts local jurisdictions from requiring anything more from banks before they foreclose.    

 “It’s clear to me it was the influence of money from financial institutions that blocked meaningful regulation of this process,” Leopold says. “The idea that they prevented local communities from doing more to help their citizens speaks for everything that is wrong with our legislative system. It’s no surprise to me that the Occupy movement has blossomed when citizens see that the system is not really geared to help them.”

Kamala Harris, the ‘Hole’ in the Bank Settlement, and Edward DeMarco

On one hand, the bank settlement has been dismissed as a “back-door bailout” for the banks by Loren Steffy, a business columnist for the Houston Chronicle, and, on the other hand it was criticized as a “shakedown” of the banks by state attorneys general in a Wall Street Journal editorial by David Skeel. The jury of public opinion is still out on whether the settlement is adequate restitution for the damage done by fraudulent foreclosures, and the exact terms of the settlement were filed in Federal court this week.  

The major obstacle in negotiations has been encouraging banks to write down the principal owed by underwater borrowers as a loss for the bank, which banks have been extremely reluctant to do in previous federally funded foreclosure prevention programs, such as the Home Affordable Modification Program (HAMP).  

The bank settlement requires more than $10 billion in principal reductions by the five banks who settled, but does not include any action be taken on the part of Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, so-called Government-Sponsored Enterprises that purchase mortgages from banks and own more than 60 percent of home mortgages in California. Excluding Fannie Mae- and Freddie Mac-owned mortgages has been called a “gaping hole” in the bank settlement by several advocates for foreclosure prevention.   

This “gaping hole” has led to a very public confrontation between Kamala Harris, the California Congressional delegation and Edward DeMarco, the acting director of the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA), which administers Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Despite pressure from the Obama administration, DeMarco has been adamantly opposed to expanding principal reductions for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans.

U.S. Representative Sam Farr wrote to GT in an email, “Economists and housing experts have repeatedly called for targeted write downs of principal balances of underwater mortgages as the surest way to ease the housing crash and rebuild our economy. Yet despite these calls, Mr. DeMarco has refused to allow Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to work towards those ends. The bottom line is that if he can’t get it done, it is time to appoint someone who can.” 

Comments (2)Add Comment
...
written by Denica De Foy, March 21, 2012
Excellent article. The speculation then subsequent crashing of our system has hurt America's most valued assets, home and family. We must take back our children's future from the 1%. For those who have not woken up or do not understand, think of a home being crashed in value by the same men who told the American people they could re-finance their most valued asset. Instead, so many saw their home value fall so far below the bank-estimated value that they ended up losing it. "Underwater" would be more accurately described as purposefully flooded. The Banks even sometimes "give away" the foreclosed homes for FURTHER Government rewards after they have stolen them - FOR PR! Wake up. Thanks, Good Times. Lets work so we can have them again.
...
written by Bill Smallman, March 20, 2012
You can spend a lot of time blaming the banks, blaming each other and wasting your time trying to develop legislation regarding the foreclosure process when the only way I see out of this crisis is economic development and jobs, jobs and more jobs. When the economy recovers, and it will, we will wonder why we had leaders who hastened its recovery by wasting time, making false promises and diverting from real solutions. Real solutions take real leadership, something that is really lacking.

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

Share this on your social networks

Bookmark and Share

Share this

Bookmark and Share

 

Dancing In the Rain

District Attorney Bob Lee’s death in October stunned the Santa Cruz community, but he had battled cancer fiercely—and privately—for more than a decade. Now one of his closest friends reveals the remarkable inside story

 

Our Gifts - Fiery Sacrificial Lights to One Another

Wednesday is Christmas Eve, Hanukkah ends and the Moon is in Aquarius, calling for the new world to take shape at midnight. Thursday morning, the sun, at the Tropic of Capricorn, begins moving northward. The desire currents are stilled. A great benediction of spiritual force (Capricorn’s Rays 1, 3, 7) streams into Earth. Temple bells ring out. The heavens bend low; the Earth is lifted up to the Light. Angels and Archangels chant, “On Earth, peace, goodwill to all.” As these forces stream into the Earth they assume long swirling lines of light, in the likeness of the Madonna and Child. The holy child is born. Let our hearts be “impressed” with and hold this picture, especially because Christmas may be difficult this year. Christmas Day is void of course moon (v/c moon), which means we may feel somewhat disconnected from one another. It’s difficult to connect in a v/c moon. Try anyway. Mercury joins Pluto in Capricorn. Uh oh … we don’t bring up the past containing any dark and difficult issues. We are to attempt new ways of communicating—expressing aspirations and love for one another, replacing wounding, sadness, lostness, and hurts of the past. Play soothing music, pray together, have the intention for peace, harmony and goodwill. Don’t be surprised if things feel out of control and/or arguments arise. We remember, before a new harmony emerges, chaos and crisis come first to clear the air. We are to be the harmonizers. Christmas evening is more harmonious, less difficult, more of what Christmas should be— radiations of love, sharing, kindness, compassion and care. Sunday, Feast Day of the Holy Family, is surprising. Wednesday is New Year’s Eve, the last day of 2014. Taurus moon, a stabilizing energy, ushers in the New Year. Happy New Year, everyone! Peace to everyone. Let us realize we are gifts radiating diamond light to one another. Living sacrificial flames!

 

The New Tech Nexus

Community leaders in science and technology unite to form web-based networking program

 

Let My People Go

There’s a lot to like in Ridley Scott’s maligned ‘Exodus’
Sign up for Good Times weekly newsletter
Get the latest news, events

RSS Feed Burner

 Subscribe in a reader

Latest Comments

 

Best Bites of 2014

A look back at the year in good taste

 

What downtown business is good for both one-stop shopping and last-minute gifts?

The Homeless Garden Project store. Because it is a community effort and has really useful and beautiful things, and allows you to connect with a lot of folks who are doing great work in Santa Cruz. Miriam Greenberg, Santa Cruz, UCSC Professor

 

Vino Tabi Winery

One of Santa Cruz’s most happening areas to go wine tasting is in the westside’s Swift Street Courtyard complex. Ever since a group of about a dozen wineries got together and formed Surf City Vintners (SCV), the place has been a hive of activity, and a wine-tasting mecca. Adding to the mix is the lively Santa Cruz Mountain Brewing beer company—making Swift Street Courtyard a perfect spot for a glass of wine or a pitcher of ale.

 

Betty’s Eat Inn

Yes, she’s a real person; no, this isn’t her