Santa Cruz Good Times

Feb 10th
Text size
  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size

Grappling with Growth

Expansion of Watsonville sparks new and long-standing issues

Watsonville City Councilmember Daniel Dodge may have opened a can of worms with a recent editorial published in the Santa Cruz Sentinel on Jan. 29. 

His piece proposed that the City of Watsonville annex a property known as Sakata-Kett for large retail development and mentioned Costco as a possible tenant.  He says this would help create jobs outside of the agricultural industry for a city whose unemployment rate has hovered around 25 percent since 2008.

“Farm workers don’t want their kids to grow up to be farm workers,” Dodge says.

A study session on the proposal at the Watsonville city council’s Feb. 14 meeting brought a slew of responses ranging from suspicion to opposition. The tone hinted at simmering mistrust of local government and history of racial division in the city that dates back to the ‘80s.

Between 1971 and 1985, nine Latino candidates ran for city council seats, but were all defeated in at-large elections, despite Watsonville’s 36 percent Latino population at that time.

This spurred a lawsuit called Gomez v. City of Watsonville in which the United States Supreme Court decided in 1988 that at-large elections discriminated against Latinos. The court imposed a district-by-district election system described in the Voting Rights Act of 1965.

In 1989 Oscar Rios won the seat representing district one and became the city’s first Latino mayor. Latinos felt that previous councils stifled development for retail and manufacturing jobs to preserve farm land mostly owned by white residents, says Luis Alejo, a former Watsonville mayor and current California assemblymember for the 28th District.

“In the ’80s [Latinos] felt they were not being represented by the council,” Alejo says. “Now they are on the city council and in every department of the local government.”

The Latino population went on to grow to 42 percent and the city’s borders stretched to build housing, businesses and schools. Action Pajaro Valley—a coalition of business, environmental and citizen activists—formed in 1998 to develop growth strategies that balanced these priorities while retaining the area’s agricultural land. Measure U was passed by 60 percent of voters in 2003, setting urban limits through 2030 and allowing annexations during that time if voters approve them.

“Trust was built through this process,” says APV Executive Director Lisa Dobbins. “Trust was not good in the ‘80s, and some people felt that the whole district election talk was too race based. White Watsonville was starting to flee, and the new elections were changing how the city was being represented.”

The demographics and priorities of the city council also transformed as the face of the city council became more diverse. The population grew from 31,199 in 1990 to 51,099 today, and is comprised of 83 percent Latino residents. Today, Latinos hold four of seven council seats. Also of note, nearly 50 percent of the city’s population is under the age of 25. Dodge says it is his responsibility as an elected official to create a future with decent jobs and houses for when these young residents start families of their own.

“I don’t want to come off as angry—rather I am hopeful,” he says. “But with how young the town is, and how high unemployment is, I’m concerned.”

He says the Sakata-Kett property is prime for a shopping center with a large anchor store because of its proximity to highly-used Highway 1. Costco was mentioned because they had talked with city officials in recent years, but no location in the city limits was suitable. They said they needed a 15-acre plot to house the store and parking lot, according to Watsonville Economic Development Director Kurt Overmeyer.

“Of 6.5 million square feet of industrial [zoned] space, less than 1 percent is undeveloped,” says Overmeyer. “We literally don’t have any space to provide developers with to build retail and fill the gap between farm work and [future job opportunities].”

The annexation of the Sakata-Kett site represents more than a building proposal to Dobbins. She says it breaks the agreement they reached under Measure U, and asks why the Manabe-Ow property—which is already in city hands—is being overlooked for a retail project.

“There are people in our group who are against a lot of sprawling but have a strong urban conscience,” Dobbins says. “How do we provide housing and good jobs for workers, and juggle conservation of land so we don’t go out willy-nilly on to agricultural land?”

Manabe-Ow and Sakata-Kett were originally proposed to be annexed together, but after years of talks between businesses, environmentalists and government, the latter was dropped from the concept. Dodge wants to resume talks on Sakata-Kett because there are several obstacles to development on Manabe-Ow (a building condemned after the Loma Prieta Earthquake sits on the site, which has to be demolished before anything new can move in).

Gov. Jerry Brown’s abolition of redevelopment agencies in 2011 strips the funds that would have helped prepare the site. Overmeyer says no developer is going to add the cost of demolition to his or her project.

“Redevelopment was a great funding gap filler that made in-fill projects possible,” he says. “We don’t have that anymore, and so we are getting creative.”

The Manabe-Ow deed, however, bans constructing “big box stores”—any store larger than 20,000 square feet—until 2030. This is too long to wait for Dodge, who says the city needs to prepare for the future now.

“Time is of the essence,” says Dodge. “On top of deed restrictions there are restrictions from the Coastal Commission put on Santa Cruz County that don’t exist anywhere else in the state that restrict development here.”

Watsonville is now the fastest-growing area in the county and is expected to surpass Santa Cruz’s population within 10 years, according to Alejo. He says the city must prepare a new economic environment because when unemployment does start dropping in south Santa Cruz County, the jobs his parents’ generation had will not be returning.

“Watsonville used to be the frozen food capital of the world,” says Alejo. “With the passage of NAFTA a lot of those jobs were sent to South America.”

Dodge’s suggested a Costco for Sakata-Kett because they are a union company with a good record of employee relations. He and APV agree that if a large store does come in, they will be choosy. Both say they are against Wal-Mart—a company that tried to open there in recent years—coming to town because of a poor record of paying low wages and denying promotions to certain groups.

“Working for John Martinelli [S. Martinell & Co.] I had health insurance, could pay my rent and have a little left over,” says Dodge, recalling an earlier Watsonville job of his. “Nowadays for a lot of people hope is a dream.”

He also says that his plan would not violate Measure U’s limits because the city’s voters would approve it if given the chance.

“I believe that about two-thirds support the annexation,” Dodge says. “I have not talked with anyone that doesn’t support it.”

He also doesn’t shy away from claims he often hears that he is trying to disenfranchise property owners who are concerned that changes to the city landscape could affect the value of their assets.

“If people want to have a conversation about race, I am happy to have it because we do live in a racially segregated county,” he says.

Only 52.5 percent of Watsonville residents over the age of 25 have high school diplomas compared with Santa Cruz, where 37 percent have bachelor’s degrees, according to the 2010 United States Census. Dodge says bringing a Costco in would raise future revenue that would help fund schools and open more opportunities to residents.

Comments (2)Add Comment
written by Emilio Martinez, March 29, 2012
Best Buy just announced that it will be closing 50 stores. They are revamping how they do business which many big box stores will soon be doing probably to increase profits. Also, Big Box stores provide mostly jobs, not careers which is what we want for our Watsonville youth, don't we?.

The plan for annexation by Mr. Dodge has not been brought forth formally to the city council. Other than city council member Dodge, members of city staff, and maybe some other council members who may have had a discussion with him (Dodge) some of us other city council members, well maybe just me, are being treated like a mushroom....kept in the dark and shoveled manure regarding the "Plan" for a Costco. In my opinion, Costco coming to Watsonville is a pipe irrigation pipe for that matter.
written by Bill Smallman, March 27, 2012
I spoke with Mr. Dodge shortly after the January 29th article, and he didn't know what type of business he wanted to build over this farm land. The Costco idea is new to me, and I remember saying to him that the City can support a certain amount of retail. I am sure Costco will study if a store at that location is viable. Farm work is noble work, it provides something we need to survive. He says Farm workers don't want their kids to be farm workers, so what you want them to be Costco workers? I say violate NAFTA and bring to frozen food industry back, or use existing warehouse space for a manufacturing business. A healthy economy depends diverse businesses, not just retail. People move where the jobs are, and we cannot continue sprawling on agriculture land. This is not San Jose in 1950. Watsonville, Salinas Valley is prime farm land and it feeds us, it feeds the world. Continued sprawl is not necessary, and economic development can improve without increasing the human footprint. It may of been OK for San Jose to sprawl, but the day now beacons to start drawing lines and preserve this land, for farm land use forever. Future generations will look back upon us as the smart ones, not the dumb ones who kicked the can down the road leading to the suffering of overpopulation and hunger.

Write comment
smaller | bigger


Share this on your social networks

Bookmark and Share

Share this

Bookmark and Share


Walking With a Ghost

How ‘ghosting’ has become a dating norm and why it needs to stop


Chinese New Year of the Red Fire Monkey

Monday, Feb. 8, is Aquarius new moon (19 degrees) and Chinese New Year of the Red Fire Monkey (an imaginative, intelligent and vigilant creature). Monkey is bright, quick, lively, quite naughty, clever, inquiring, sensible, and reliable. Monkey loves to help others. Often they are teachers, writers and linguists. They are very talented, like renaissance people. Leonardo Da Vinci was born in the year of Monkey. Monkey contains metal (relation to gold) and water (wisdom, danger). 2016 will be a year of finances. For a return on one’s money, invest in monkey’s ideas. Metal is related to wind (change). Therefore events in 2016 will change very quickly. We must ponder with care before making financial, business and relationship changes. Fortune’s path may not be smooth in 2016. Finances and business as usual will be challenged. Although we develop practical goals, the outcomes are different than hoped for. We must be cautious with investments and business partnership. It is most important to cultivate a balanced and harmonious daily life, seeking ways to release tension, pressure and stress to improve health and calmness. Monkey is lively, flexible, quick-witted, and versatile. Their gentle, honest, enchanting yet resourceful nature results often in everlasting love. Monkeys are freedom loving. Without freedom, Monkey becomes dull, sad and very unhappy. During the Spring and Autumn Period (770 - 476 BC), the Chinese official title of Marquis (noble person) was pronounced ‘Hou,’ the same as the pronunciation of ‘monkey’ in Chinese. Monkey was thereby bestowed with auspicious (favorable, fortunate) meaning. Monkey years are: 1920, 1932, 1944, 1956, 1968, 1980, 1992, 2004, 2016.  


The New Tech Nexus

Community leaders in science and technology unite to form web-based networking program


Film, Times & Events: Week of February 5

Santa Cruz area movie theaters >
Sign up for Good Times weekly newsletter
Get the latest news, events

RSS Feed Burner

 Subscribe in a reader

Latest Comments


Pub Watch

Mega gastro pub-in-progress at the Old Sash Mill, plus the best pasta dish downtown


How would you stop people from littering?

Teach them from the time that they’re small that it’s not an appropriate behavior. Juliet Jones, Santa Cruz, Claims Adjuster


Dancing Creek Winery

New Zinfandel Port is a ruby beauty


Wine and Chocolate

West Cliff Wines gets its game on, plus a brand new chocolate cafe on Center Street