Santa Cruz Good Times

Friday
Oct 24th
Text size
  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size

Living The Dream

news1-1Locals react to decision to provide work permits to undocumented youth

UC Santa Cruz psychology major Carmen Macias never knew she was undocumented while growing up. She came to the United States when she was 3 years old from Jalisco, Mexico, a place she doesn’t remember. Her family never spoke of her undocumented status.

When her parents and her teachers at Los Angeles public schools stressed that education was key to her future, Macias embraced the notion. Attending college became a goal and a dream.

By the time she was a senior in high school, she had applied to campuses in the University of California and California State University systems and, with her good grades, was sure to be admitted. But when she began filling out financial aid applications in one of her classes, a form asked for a Social Security number—which she didn’t have. Her twin sister was in that same class.

“Both of us started having more questions,” recalls Macias. “It didn’t make sense. Why don’t we have one? Then we pretty much understood that we were undocumented.”

By persevering, and by taking advantage of Assembly Bill 540, a California law that allows undocumented students to pay in-state tuition, Macias was eventually admitted to UCSC. And as big of a victory as that was for her, there is another one looming on the horizon.

On June 15, President Barack Obama announced that his administration would grant temporary work permits to certain undocumented young people who came to the country with their parents. Those who meet certain criteria can apply for a status known as deferred action. If Macias has her application approved, she will be able to legally seek employment for the first time in her life.

“I’m definitely really excited,” says Macias. “Before Obama’s announcement, my plan was to do grad school right after graduating. But now, I want to work for the two years I will have the work permit.”

Without the act she would have been in the untenable position of having a college degree, but with no legal right to work. The decision offers a welcome reprieve—and while she knows it’s temporary, she’s optimistic about the future.

“Everything changes now,” says Macias.

news1-2Ana Navarrete, an intern at UC Santa Cruz's Educational Opportunities Programs office, helps an undocumented student craft an annual budget. The DREAM Act, which has languished in Congress for 10 years, was intended to accomplish the same goal, but in a more thorough and comprehensive fashion. The essential idea behind both the DREAM Act and the president’s announced action is to rectify the policy of punishing children who emigrated to the United States with their parents.

Doug Keegan, program director of the Santa Cruz County Immigration Project, likens it to prosecutorial discretion. The Department of Homeland Security will defer action on deportation proceedings, halting deportations of law-abiding young people who meet certain criteria to countries they have no memory of.

“In addition, those not in deportation or removal, but who would otherwise meet the eligibility criteria, will be able to apply affirmatively for status under this new policy,” says Keegan.

A key difference from the DREAM Act is that the current action is only temporary.

“Some practitioners are questioning if young people should even apply for this program, because much of it hinges on the election in November,” says Keegan, explaining that a future president could rescind the decision.

The Pew Research Center estimates that up to 1.4 million people could benefit from deferred action, out of an estimated 11.2 million undocumented immigrants nationwide (as of 2010). It does not create a path to permanent residency or citizenship.

“The good thing is you get a work permit while you are concurrently receiving deferred action,” says Keegan. “It’s not as good as a green card, [or] a residency card, but it does allow you to work, get a Social Security number and a driver’s license or I.D.”

Shannon Gleeson, assistant professor of Latin American & Latino Studies at UCSC, thinks the decision by the Obama administration is a step in the right direction, but falls short of a full-fledged DREAM Act.

“My great grandfather came to this country from Kiev almost a century ago,” says Gleeson. “He went on to be very successful, in large part because the political environment at that time helped to cultivate and supported his ambition. We don’t know how many lives or success stories we are not actuating because the political environment hasn’t caught up with the demographic reality. These individuals are no less promising and capable than the European immigrants from a century ago.”

A Bloomberg poll on June 19 showed 64 percent of likely voters agreed with the president’s action. Independent voters backed the decision by more than a two-to-one margin.

Reactions in Congress differed mostly along party lines. Congressman Sam Farr (D-Santa Cruz), who has co-sponsored every version of the DREAM Act, is pleased but wants more.

“I am still waiting on the guidelines from the Department of Homeland Security regarding how the program will be implemented but right now it appears to be a good step towards sensible immigration policy,” says Farr. “However, the president’s announcement to allow deferred action is only a temporary fix; it is not a permanent solution. We need to develop common sense approaches, like the full DREAM Act and comprehensive immigration reform, to fix our broken immigration system.

House Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio) criticized the decision. In an interview with the news website Politico, Boehner stated “the president’s actions are going to make it much more difficult for us to work in a bipartisan way to get to a permanent solution.”

But proponents say the action is needed due to congressional inaction.

“The DREAM Act started out 10 years ago as a bi-partisan act,” says Jonathan Fox, chair of UCSC’s department of Latin American and Latino Studies. “[Conservative] Sen. Orrin Hatch was one of the sponsors. As the Republicans took a harder and harder line, those Republicans who were open to what looked like a no-brainer act, withdrew their support. There’s no more room in the Republican Party for anything but the hardest of hard lines.”

When Macias discovered that she was undocumented, she didn’t have time to deal with the emotions that came along with the realization. She didn’t even discuss it with the rest of her family.

“Within my family … it’s still something we don’t speak about,” says Macias. “It’s very difficult.”

Instead, she turned her attention into figuring out if there was a way she could still go to college.

“My sister and I looked at the prices of tuition. At this point we knew we had no scholarships,” says Macias. “We asked [ourselves],  ‘Can we afford it, can my parents afford it?’ And the answer was pretty much no—there were two of us. So, I guess at that point we just stopped thinking of college, and went along with the flow.”

She ended up taking a low-paying job at a fast food restaurant after graduating from high school in 2007.

That fall she began classes at East Los Angeles College (ELAC), a community college, while continuing to work night shifts at the restaurant that ended at 1 a.m. Despite her undocumented status—or perhaps because of it—Macias became politically active at ELAC.

“I started organizing, being more active with the community,” says Macias. “I started learning about more scholarships and resources. That began my transition to UCSC.”

She learned that as an undocumented student who attended high school in California, AB 540 allowed her to pay in-state tuition at public institutions such as UCSC. California’s DREAM Act, passed in 2011, allowed AB 540 students to apply for non-state-funded scholarships, and later added state aid such as Cal Grants.

Though UCSC does not keep a count of undocumented students, a friend sold Macias on the school because of the resources it provides for undocumented students.

Macias continues to advocate for the rights of immigrants at UCSC with the group Students Informing Now. While she counts herself fortunate to benefit from the Obama decision, she also recognizes the tenuousness of her status.

“It’s a starting point, but it’s a very small victory,” says Macias. “We have to continue fighting because people like my parents are not going to benefit from this. Even some of the teen activists who began this movement [are] no longer eligible [because of age restrictions]. We definitely have to continue pushing.”   

Comments (6)Add Comment
...
written by Crys, July 20, 2012
Why hasn't she applied for citizenship? If she has "known" since she was 18 and she has since graduated from college (4 years) I'm assuming she has had more than enough time to apply for citizenship and practically meet the 5 year requirement. But is it still so much of "shock" to her, she hasn't had the time to apply? I guess it's better taking advantage as a illegal than applying and having to pay taxes like a citizen. Typical.
...
written by Don Honda, July 20, 2012
Add to my Macias comment:

1.4+ Million Work Permits to Illegal Aliens while 14 Million+ of US Citizens unemployed/underemployed. Please tell me how this isn't ludicrous or political pandering.
...
written by Deb Abbott, July 20, 2012
Thanks to Dave and the Good Times for a clear, informative article on what can be a confusing issue to many people. Gratitude to Carmen for being willing to share her powerful and moving story. And to Sam Farr for his persistence in working to pass the DREAM Act.
...
written by G Rowe, July 19, 2012
Many of our industries have always enjoyed near-slave labor, be it China, prisoners or black slaves. Many companies and government leaders have been happy to allow poor people into this country and make sure Mexico never developed a sizeable middle class. Blocking the borders was never a priority til the right wing drove the economy into the ground and the Tea Party started screaming "Wolf". Our republican duty is to find a way to live with coherence and respect - like we do with all members of our community.
...
written by Don Honda, July 18, 2012
How did Macias get a job at a fast food restaurant without having a Social Security number????? Illegal Aliens are doing the jobs US Citizens don't want to do? I don't think so. And, now with Obama's deferred action and work permits, they definitely will be taking jobs that US Citizens DO want to do. Insanity.
...
written by Don Honda, July 18, 2012
Please, please, please do not fall into the pseudo-jounalistic jargon spin of using the term "immigrants". We are talking about Illegal Aliens in this article. To use the term "immigrants" is doing a great disservice to those who abide by the rules and laws of our immigration system and take the time to become US Citizens. It is they who are being harmed by this and any other amnesty put forth by disrespecting their efforts in honoring our values.

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

Share this on your social networks

Bookmark and Share

Share this

Bookmark and Share

 

Santa Cruz Restaurant Week

A huge part of Santa Cruz Restaurant Week has always been about offering a great dining experience for an affordable price. For some locals, the $25 flat-rate cost has provided the opportunity (or the excuse!) to try new spots, and indulge in Santa Cruz fine dining in a way they might have thought too pricey before.

 

Scorpio Sun, New Moon Eclipse, Mercury Direct

The Sun enters Scorpio’s mysteries Thursday under a new moon and partial solar eclipse (something essential has come to an end, its purpose completed). In Scorpio we harbor secrets, are devoted to something deep, dark and hidden. Sometimes it’s ourselves. We can bring great suspect to our assessment of others. Scorpio is the scorpion, the serpent and the eagle—three levels of development. As the serpent we take shelter in our beliefs. Sometimes we bite (or sting). The eagle vanquishes old beliefs through its sharp intellect, soaring high in the air, seeking to understand through perspective. Understanding releases us from the bondage of fear. The eagle is like the mother soothing feelings of mistrust, offering protection. Knowledge does this, too.

 

The New Tech Nexus

Community leaders in science and technology unite to form web-based networking program

 

Light Humor

College comedy questions a post-racial America in ‘Dear White People’
Sign up for Good Times weekly newsletter
Get the latest news, events

RSS Feed Burner

 Subscribe in a reader

Latest Comments

 

Back Porch

Austin Kaye on backyard dinners and why it’s his favorite time of year to be a chef

 

What’s the most outrageous situation you ever saw at a restaurant?

Damani Thomas, Santa Cruz, Chef/Owner

 

Wine Lust

The Spanish Godello grape, plus arancinis, tender butter lettuce and pork schnitzel at Soif

 

What artist or artists participating in the encore weekend of Open Studios should not be missed?

Santa Cruz | Teacher