Santa Cruz Good Times

Wednesday
Sep 02nd
Text size
  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size

Family Ties

news DNA

UPDATE: On Thursday, July 18, jurors found Elvis Garcia guilty of seven felonies, including sodomy, sexual battery, burglary and kidnapping after deliberating for just two hours. The DNA evidence was key, jurors and attorneys said.

"Clearly that was the most important piece of evidence," defense attorney James Reilly said. The trial ended about two to three weeks earlier than originally anticipated, Judge Timothy Volkmann said. Reilly did not make opening statements nor did he put any witnesses on the stand, though he said he originally considered having Garcia testify. Garcia faces up to life in prison with the possibility of parole when he is sentenced Oct. 2.

Brutal rape trial hinges on familial DNA technology

A hairnet, a plastic bottle and a father’s vehicle theft conviction led to the arrest of a Santa Cruz man currently on trial for a heinous March 2008 rape.

The trial of Elvis Garcia, which began July 1 and is expected to last through the month, hinges largely on DNA evidence that prosecutors say was linked to him through his father. The younger Garcia’s arrest was just the second time in California that a case was solved using what’s called familial DNA. The technology wasn’t approved in the state until 2008, and remains prohibited in a handful of other states.

Still, it’s quickly gaining traction among prosecutors and law enforcement agencies, garnering attention most recently in a 50-year-old murder and sex assault in Massachusetts. On July 11, authorities in Boston announced that a familial DNA search had been used to link Albert DeSalvo to the last of the 1960s killings attributed to the so-called Boston Strangler.

In the local case, Garcia is accused of raping a then-23-year-old barista inside the Kind Grind coffeehouse in the Santa Cruz Harbor as she prepared for her morning shift. An intruder entered, sexually assaulted her at knifepoint and robbed the shop. He then barricaded the woman inside a large refrigerator before fleeing.

It was “every woman’s nightmare,” Santa Cruz County prosecutor Michael Gilman said during the trial’s opening remarks earlier this month. “The physical evidence in this case shows the defendant is the man who committed these crimes.”

In the wake of the rape, Santa Cruz police held community safety meetings, distributed a sketch of the suspect and established a reward fund. Swabs of DNA evidence collected during a sexual assault exam performed on the victim were sent to a state Department of Justice laboratory for testing, along with pieces of her underwear and other clothing.

But the DNA didn’t match any of the nearly two million DNA profiles in the state’s database. The U.S. Supreme Court ruled last month that police have the right to collect DNA from people they arrest, not just those convicted of crimes. The court’s 5-4 ruling came after a challenge to a Maryland law allowing the collection from anyone arrested for a violent felony. The decision could have an impact on challenges to a similar, but broader law in California, which requires anyone arrested for a felony to submit to a mouth swab. That genetic evidence can be processed and put into a state data bank at any time. However, if charges are dropped or the person is acquitted, their DNA isn’t automatically expunged from the state database. A person has to actually apply to have it removed.

Finding themselves at a dead end in the harbor rape case, Santa Cruz police investigators requested that state officials perform a familial DNA search.

This method involves using DNA samples from convicted criminals to track down relatives who may be the perpetrators. It’s based on the scientific concept that close relatives—parents, siblings and children—will have more genetic data in common than unrelated individuals. Once an investigative lead is generated by such a search, it must ultimately be confirmed by a DNA comparison between the suspect and evidence from the crime scene, says Michelle Gregory, a spokeswoman with the state Department of Justice. California was one of the first states to permit such searches.

“If it can be shown there is an offender in the DNA database whose profile is a close but not exact match to the evidence (that is, the suspect’s) profile with a high likelihood of being related, detectives can then follow up on this investigative lead,” Gregory writes in an email to GT.

Proponents of using the process argue that it’s necessary to close many cases that otherwise would go unsolved, but opponents question the implications for privacy and personal rights.

The National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (NACDL) came out against familial DNA searching earlier this year.

“After vigorous discussion and debate, NACDL’s board opposed the use of familial DNA searching during criminal investigations because of the potential for abuse and disparate impact,” says President Steven D. Benjamin. “In a perfect world, such searches would not be conducted. But since they are a reality, NADCL also adopted proposed restrictions that, if adopted in federal and state legislation, will ensure that familial DNA searches are conducted in the fairest manner possible.”

Criminalists at the state Department of Justice lab in Richmond checked DNA taken from the Santa Cruz crime scene against state databases. In late 2010, they found a partial match with Lorenzo Garcia, who had previously been convicted of felony vehicle theft in Southern California.

Investigators ruled out Lorenzo Garcia as the suspect and began focusing their investigation on his son, Elvis Garcia, who lived just doors from the victim in the Seabright neighborhood. They collected a hairnet and a Gatorade bottle from his garbage can and tested it for DNA. When police got a match, they were able to obtain an arrest warrant. Garcia was arrested and cheek swabs were taken. When a match was made to the evidence collected from the scene, Garcia was charged with the crime’s commission.

He faces life in prison if he’s convicted of the charges against him, which include sodomy, penetration, kidnapping and robbery. 

Comments (0)Add Comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

Share this on your social networks

Bookmark and Share

Share this

Bookmark and Share

 

You Are What You Post

Online personality algorithms put astrological profiles to shame, but UCSC psychologists are raising questions about sharing personal data

 

Venus Direct, Mercury Retro Soon, Honoring Our Labors

As Burning Man (nine days, Aug. 30-Sept. 7 in the sign of Virgo) burns in the hot white desert sands, a petal of the rose created by retrograde Venus and the twelve-petaled Sun in Virgo’s petals unfold. All of us are on the burning ground (Leo) in the womb (cave of the heart) of the mother (Virgo), gestating for humanity once again (each year) a new state of consciousness. Both Virgo and Cancer, feminine (receptive energies) signs, are from our last solar system (Pleiades). When humanity first appeared on Earth we were nurtured by the mother, a matriarchy of energies (on islands in the Pacific). Eve, Isis and Mary are part of the lineages of our ancient Mother. Overseen by the Pleiades, the Earth (matter, mater, the mother) in that last solar system was imbued with intelligence (Ray 3). As we move toward autumn, another mother, Ceres realizes she has mere weeks left with her beloved daughter, Persephone. Persimmon and pomegranate trees prepare for autumn, their colors signs of hope as the light each day continues to dim. Sunday, Venus in Leo turns stationary direct, yet continues in her shadow until Oct. 9 (when retrograde Mercury turns direct). Slowly our newly assessed values emerge from the Venus retrograde. We thought in Venus retro how to use our resources more effectively. Mercury retrogrades Sept. 17. Monday is Labor Day. Let us honor the labor of everyone, all life a “labor.” Let us honor Labor Day and all those who have “served” (labored for) us this past year. We honor their labors. We honor the labor of our parents, those who have loved us. We honor our own labors, too. We are all in service, we are all laboring. We are all valuable.

 

The New Tech Nexus

Community leaders in science and technology unite to form web-based networking program

 

Girl Gone Wild

’70s SF recalled in raw, poignant ‘Diary of a Teenage Girl’
Sign up for Good Times weekly newsletter
Get the latest news, events

RSS Feed Burner

 Subscribe in a reader

Latest Comments

 

Sushi Garden

Local sushi empire expands to Scotts Valley

 

Do you overshare online?

I don’t think so. I just post things about my life, like successful things. Sometimes I just like sharing different news that I find interesting, or favorite artists, clothes, music. I like to post photos. Natalia Delgado, Santa Cruz, Server

 

McIntyre Vineyards

I recently met up with three friends for dinner at Sanderlings at Seascape Beach Resort. We chose to eat outside so we could watch the sun set over the ocean, but the Aptos fog rolled in and swallowed it up.

 

Sustainable Supper

The Homeless Garden Project’s Sustain Supper series supports its award-winning programs